All right, the hitting (or lack thereof) is becoming a problem.
The Giants did not play like World Series champions during their three-game stopover in Milwaukee this weekend. Heck, they barely played like major league baseball players. Ironically enough, the least experienced major leaguer on the team - Brandon Crawford, the 24-year-old rookie called up from the San Jose minor league team Thursday - was the most productive hitter. The four runs scored by Crawford’s magnificent seventh-inning grand slam on Friday accounted for two-thirds of all the Giants’ earned runs this series. Yes, you read that right - of the six times a Giant crossed home plate not due to an error, four of them were the result of a single swing of the bat, and by a rookie, no less. The rest of the Giants combined - each and every one of whom has more experience in the majors than Crawford - produced just two earned runs across these three games.
That’s sad.
It’s sad because the team has fallen a half-game out of first place (behind the Arizona Diamondbacks, if you can believe it). It’s sad because it indicates how anemic the Giants’ offense truly is - plenty of other Major League Baseball teams could give up 13 runs over the course of three games and still win all of them, or at least win the series. And it’s sad because the Giants’ ace pitching staff deserves better than this. Tim Lincecum pitched capably on Friday, but only got the win because of Crawford’s (entirely unexpected) long hit. Jonathan Sanchez, so inconsistent throughout his career, struck out seven and gave up just two hits over seven very strong innings yesterday, but his team couldn’t back him up with enough runs to win the game. (Fortunately for Sanchez, the loss was officially attributed to veteran reliever Guillermo Mota; but for the team as a whole, a loss is a loss is a loss.) Matt Cain had a bit of an off-day today; but every pitcher is going to give up five runs or more a few times in his career. Still, his batters couldn’t even muster one run of support for him. Ouch.
If this series is an indication of how the Giants are going to play without Buster Posey this season, then a World Series repeat is impossible, and even making it to the postseason seems like a long shot. Perhaps the return of Pablo Sandoval will inject some life into the offense, but even if it does, we’re in for a long couple of weeks before then. That’s valuable time during which either the Rockies or the Diamondbacks, or both, could overtake the reigning champs in the National League West. By mid-June, it’s not unlikely that the Giants could be second or even third in the division.
How badly, exactly, did they play?
The overall team batting average this weekend was a meager .206 - and nine of the team’s 20 hits came from just two players, Aubrey Huff and Freddy Sanchez. Both men have been showing significant improvement in recent days (particularly Sanchez, who notched his 1,000th career hit this afternoon), but two bats cannot carry a team. Several players were stagnant at the plate - third baseman Miguel Tejada, once the MVP of the American League (back when Barack Obama was a part-time Illinois legislator, Saddam Hussein still ruled Iraq, and Lady Gaga dressed like a normal person), couldn’t eke out a clean hit in any of his seven at-bats. Andres Torres came to the plate eight times, with the same results - though he did draw two walks that eventually became runs. Pat "The Bat" Burrell, once upon a time lauded for his ability to bat in runs in clutch situations, came to the plate nine times and struck out during four of them. Cody “The Boss” Ross, who came home to a well-deserved hero’s welcome after the 2010 postseason, had nothing to show for his five at-bats.
Extra-base hits? You could count them on one hand. Heck, you could lose a couple of fingers in an industrial accident and still count them on one hand. Across all three games, just two batters doubled (not surprisingly, they were Sanchez and Huff), and just one - the rookie “Babe” Crawford - hit a home run. Three extra-base hits in 97 at-bats. Ouch.
With regards to Buster Posey’s two replacements, offensively, let’s be fair - it’s hard to replace a solid hitter like Buster. But Eli Whiteside and Chris Stewart, the team's catching squad with Posey out, struck out three times and pulled out just a single hit in their 10 combined at-bats. One hit in ten opportunities? I'm not sure Posey couldn't hit better than that, even with his leg in a cast.
The pitching was almost certainly better than the hitting, but few of the pitchers were at their best. Among the starters, Sanchez was by far the most impressive; in yesterday’s game, he pitched seven innings and allowed just two hits, while striking out seven and issuing four walks, a low number by his standards. Lincecum started off the series with a seven-inning outing in which he gave up three earned runs and seven hits, walking none but striking out only four. I don’t have the stats from his college playing days on hand, but I’m guessing those numbers would have represented a pretty good outing for him as a student-athlete. As a two-time Cy Young Award winner, though, that’s just an average game. Cain, as I mentioned earlier, seems to have taken an off-day today. He allowed an abnormally-high 11 hits and five runs, all earned, while striking out six and walking one. There was no way this offensively braindead team was going to produce enough runs for Cain to earn a win, and even if they had, he didn't pitch like he deserved to.
The bullpen, as usual, was solid, with moments of greatness and only occasional disappointment seeping through. Collectively, Giants relief pitchers worked six innings across this series, during which they gave up three runs (two earned), six hits, and five walks, striking out seven. The best relief work, by far, came from Sergio Romo, who pitched less than two innings and struck out four, giving up no hits and one walk. Less impressive was Guillermo Mota, brought in to pitch the bottom of the ninth inning of yesterday’s game, which was tied 2-2 when he came in. Talk about having an off-day; in less than 20 pitches, Mota allowed consecutive singles by Ryan Braun and Prince Fielder, then issued a walk to Yuniesky Betancourt that loaded the bases. With only one out on the board, all Wil Nieves had to do was bunt the ball directly in front of home plate, by which time Braun was already halfway home from third base, scoring the walk-off run to win the game. Mota was credited with the loss for the game, and quite deservedly so.
Okay, maybe I’m being too harsh on my beloved Giants. In fact, I probably am. I really do love this team, and I understand that they are heavily demoralized - shocked and saddened by the loss of their two finest hitters (Sandoval and Posey), one only temporarily, one likely for the entire season. The multitude of other injuries has been tough to deal with, as well - Mike Fontenot, while mediocre as a hitter, is capable and limber at shortstop; and Darren Ford didn’t get the nickname “The Bullet” for no reason. Without all of them, this team is hurting, no doubt about that. If the 2010 Giants were a ragtag group of “castoffs and misfits,” as they became known, then the 2011 incarnation is even more so.
Still, a .206 batting average over a three-game series is simply not going to cut it. In the world of baseball, things change quickly, and teams have to adapt instantly; this isn’t football, where an injury to a player in one game means that the team has six full days after that to find a replacement player and come up with a new strategy. With Buster Posey down and out, every other hitter needs to produce more for this team to even stay competitive, let alone to win the division and make it to the postseason. Aubrey Huff and Freddy Sanchez seem like that’s just what they’re doing; now it’s time for Miguel Tejada, Cody Ross, Eli Whiteside, Pat Burrell, and all of their teammates to do the same. They all need to - well, not just to step up to the plate (literally), but to step up to the plate and remind everyone that they are the defending champions. They can't afford to wait until Sandoval is back in two (or more) weeks; they certainly can't afford to wait until midsummer trades and acquisitions are made, or until rosters expand in early September. They need to bring the bats to life, and they need to do it now.
Let’s go, Giants. Let’s go.